by Claire Chawk

In the early years of my career, I worked my way up through a global automotive organisation’s graduate management scheme, the kind with a proud promote-from-within culture, where every leader starts at entry level and progression is a badge of honour.

When I became a Branch Manager, I was responsible for the four core pillars of the business: profitability, growth, customer service, and employee development. I worked hard and delivered consistently across all of them, but it was in developing people that I truly found my purpose. Seeing others grow and succeed gave me the greatest sense of fulfilment and in just over two years, around 50 people from my branch were promoted. It became informally known as the “promotion factory” and looking back, it remains one of my proudest moments that my commitment to nurturing future leaders was recognised with the Women of the Future Award (Business Category, 2018).

On paper, I was exactly what the organisation said it valued.

The first opportunity and rejection

A Group Talent Development role came up at Head Office. It felt like a natural step for me, a chance to scale the work I was already doing so well. I interviewed but was unsuccessful.

The feedback was both measured and logical: Head Office roles were designed to help people strengthen in areas they struggled with. Because employee development was already my strength, I “didn’t need” this role. The successful candidate was someone who found developing their own team a challenge and would benefit from this exposure as preparation for a future Area Manager position. Instead, I was advised to take on a larger branch, positioning me for my “inevitable” promotion through the operational pathway the scheme was built around.

It made sense and so I accepted it.

The second opportunity and rejection

A month later, I was encouraged to interview for a larger branch.

Again I was unsuccessful.

This time, the feedback was different but equally disheartening. I was told the area needed me to remain where I was, as “lead” Branch Manager, to stabilise and support the less experienced managers around me. My current Area Manager was described as disorganised and transactional, and my role was to compensate for that. The Area Manager of the larger branch I had applied for was described as structured and pragmatic — much like me. I was told I wouldn’t “learn anything” from them because we were too similar. The successful candidate, instead, was chosen to “balance” that leader’s style.

The Realisation

That was the moment I felt something shift.

Not in my performance, but in my belief that performance alone determined progression. For the first time, I questioned whether excellence was enough — and realised I wasn’t being held back for lacking capability, but for being too valuable where I was.

What became apparent was that progression wasn’t the point, positioning was. Decisions were being made to optimise the wider organisation, placing leaders where they were most needed to mitigate others’ shortcomings.

I understood the strategy, but the cost was still mine to carry.

The Cost

The approach prioritised organisational balance over individual performance and progression. Hard-working, high-performing employees were left disillusioned, and although I continued to lead positively and build resilience through repeated setbacks, my loyalty and long-term commitment to the company, developed over more than six years, began to erode.

The Outcome

I began seeking opportunities elsewhere, pursuing an environment where my contribution would be recognised, career progression aligned with my passion and performance, and professional development could flourish, unhampered by wider organisational limitations.

Reflection for the reader

This story isn’t about not getting a role. At its heart, it’s about being high-performing yet strategically “parked” and being told your strengths disqualify you.

It’s the quiet tension many of you may recognise: When being excellent at your job begins to work against you, and workforce planning feels personal.

Organisations must balance what’s right for the business with what’s right for the individual.

However when excellence becomes the reason your career stands still, when leaders are positioned like pieces on a chessboard for organisational gain rather than career development,  the message is clear: Those who are “too valuable where they are” will eventually move somewhere they are empowered and where organisational success and professional growth align.

We’d love to hear your story
If there’s a moment, challenge, or turning point you think others could learn from, we invite you to submit your blog for consideration as part of the In Their Shoes series. You don’t even need to publish your name, anonymous submissions are welcome. Sometimes, sharing your experience, in whatever way feels safest for you, is exactly what someone else needs to hear.
Get in touch